|
- Piano
Concerto No. 1 in F sharp minor Op. 1; Piano Concerto No.
2 in C minor Op. 18; Piano Concerto No. 3 in D minor Op. 30;
Piano Concerto No. 4; Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini Op.
43
Matthew Rye, The Daily Telegraph, 1
November 2004
'Recordings of Rachmaninov's ever-popular piano concertos
are hardly rarities, so they need to be distinctive to justify
their place in the catalogue. This new complete set from Stephen
Hough, recorded live in Dallas this summer, has plenty to
recommend it. Not least is the authenticist's approach he
has brought to the music: listening to the composer's own
recordings from the 1930s and 1940s has made him realise how
much has been lost in the intervening decades.
While in no way doggedly following Rachmaninov's
performances, he has at least tried to inject his own with
their spirit and style. This is most noticeable in two main
respects: the generally fast tempos (the long opening tune
of Concerto No 2 surges rather than drifts along), and the
frequent little sliding portamenti from the orchestral strings.
But the freshness and joy in rediscovering well-worn masterpieces
are everywhere in evidence in Hough's playing.
It is crisp and sparkling where some of his
contemporaries seem determined to add unwanted weight; and
a subtle use of rubato - very much part of the Rachmaninov
style - gets away from today's tendency towards metronomic
doggedness. Andrew Litton is a real re-creative partner in
this project (even transcribing some lost wind parts from
the composer's recording), and the Dallas Symphony Orchestra
plays magnificently, from the suavity of the smallest instrumental
solo to the grit and power of its ensemble. If you think you
have heard these pieces once too often, this is the recording
to help you rediscover their intimacies and their emotional
sweep.'
BBC Music Magazine, November 2004
'No less distinct are the First Concerto’s deliciously
dovetailed rubatos in the first movement and the finale’s
perfectly gauged rhythmic definition…Overall, these
live concert recordings stand out in a field jam-packed with
first-rate Rachmaninov concerto cycles.'
Disc of the Month, 5 Stars, Classic
FM Magazine, November 2004
'Stephen Hough proves that you don’t have to
be Russian to play Rachmaninov – in fact, he gets closer
to what the composer really intended than many others. Hough’s
playing is sheer poetry and his technique awesome.
…an ideal confluence it is, with these
beloved concertos getting fresh and original interpretations
that lift them above the dozens available in the catalogue…fresh,
ardent, and passionate, full of a youthful, heart-on-sleeve
innocence.
[Third Piano Concerto] Hough is simply dazzling,
in a performance full of light and shade, from the thunderous
passion of the outer movements to the poetic and mercurial
elements of the central one. Hough’s technique is breathtaking:
he can play with tremendous power but still finds a way to
phrase subtly even the most gargantuan passages.
Overall, these are outstanding performances.
The recordings capture the excitement of the live concerts…This
is a release that’s bound to win all the awards.'
5 Stars, The Irish Times, 23 October
2004
'Stephen Hough’s recordings of Rachmaninov’s four
piano concertos…exhibit an electrical charge and emotional
sweep that are rarely caught with such consistency in the
recording studio. If you like your Rachmaninov with sentiment
rather than sentimentality, if the ardent, spur-of-the-moment
seeming impetuosity of the composer’s own recordings
is to your taste, and if you’re as concerned about issues
of style in the treatment of 20th-century as most people seem
to be in case of early music, then the impassioned and daring
Hough and his equally fearless partner [DSO/Litton]…are
the men for you.'
5 Stars, The Times, 23 October 2004
'Stephen Hough is a pianist of immense finesse, who is incapable
of playing a vulgar or exaggerated note. And he has a steely
technique, secure enough to carry him through four live recordings
– which these are – with barely a slip. He has
also immersed himself in the performing tradition of these
pieces, which allows him to escape the routine that so often
afflicts them…Overall, this is a wonderful release.'
5 Stars, The Guardian, 22 October 2004
'Stephen Hough’s dash through Rachmaninov puts him on
the winner’s podium – What Hough has come up with
is much fleeter and leaner than the overripe romantic effects
usually lavished on these concertos…he keeps the music
on the move, carefully regulating its ebb and flow, so that
Rachmaninov’s melodies float above the harmonic feints
and sidesteps…As fine as anything Hough has done on
disc to date.'
5 Stars, The Scotsman, 15 October 2004
'…a vigorously cleansing new release from British pianist
Stephen Hough. His reading of the Paganini Rhapsody is pin-sharp,
but gorgeously expressive with it. All in all, this is an
electrifying double-disc set.'
Classical CD of the Week, 4 Stars (out
of 4), The Sunday Times, October 2004
'These are exhilarating performances, freshly conceived and
texturally pristine…With such committed advocacy and
technical bravura, Hough’s interpretations demand to
be heard.'
Classical CD of the Week, The Observer,
10 October 2004
5 Stars, The Independent (The Information),
2-8 October 2004
'[Stephen Hough]’s new recordings demonstrate his genius
in spectacular style. These bravura performances recall the
composer’s own.'
The Times, 1 October 2004
'…they make living, flaming music from the ebbing and
flowing speeds, the soloist’s improvisatory airs, or
the strings’ willingness to revive portamento slide.
The waves of energy at the finale’s end are very exciting:
no wonder the Dallas audience break out in cheers.'
5 Stars, Evening Standard, 1 October
2004
International Record Review, October
2004
'[First Piano Concerto]…Hough delivers a cadenza at
first with thundering power and then with opulent lyricism.
His sound is enormous, but always sonorous. The lovely horn
opening to the slow movement is complemented by the ruminative
melancholy of Hough’s opening passage – a beautiful
sonority characterized by a beguiling alto register. And then
he imparts to the finale all the feverish passions of headstrong
youth.'
'Hough’s vision of the Second is confident,
full-blooded, unapologetically emotive, with a slow movement
of truly ravishing intensity...it’s a tremendous performance…
And the Third, explosive, powerful, dramatic, is given the
complete performance which seems to sum up all that Rachmaninov
was about. A superb achievement, and that is all that needs
to be said.'
Editor’s Choice, The Gramophone,
Awards Issue 2004
'Have there been more electric recordings of these works since
the composer’s own? – Stephen Hough is a pianist
of staggering virtuosity but also with a deep-seated musicality.
His thorough knowledge of the Romantic repertoire makes him
an ideal advocate for this music…
There is so much to applaud…not even
Rachmaninov caresses the second subject of the First Concerto’s
finale so beguilingly; the notoriously tricky opening pages
of the Second Concerto’s finale are dispatched with
breathtaking élan, as is the last movement of the Third
Concerto…It is quite an achievement when each of Hough’s
five performances here rival the greatest versions recorded
individually by other pianists.'
SoundStage!, Wes Marshall, December
2004
'I've been wondering when some intelligent record
company would finally bring Andrew Litton and Rachmaninov
back together again. His highly acclaimed set of the symphonies
with the Royal Philharmonic ([Virgin Classics 59279], sadly
no longer available) is still the one I turn to most often,
both for sumptuous sonics and a true sense of the composer's
ultra-romantic, opulent sound.
Litton is never afraid of showing some emotion,
precisely what is needed for convincing Rachmaninov. Stephen
Hough's ability in the romantic repertoire is well documented
through his recordings on Hyperion, for which he's received
a mantelpiece full of awards. Can you tell I had high expectations
for this set?Apparently not high enough! Time and again, I
was amazed at the felicitous surprises Hough and Litton seem
to have discovered in the score.
From the martial beat six minutes into the
first movement of the Second Concerto to the delicate skittle
as Litton holds the orchestra in perfect balance with Hough
in Variation X of the Rhapsody, details were exposed with
precision. When it came time for some heart, like the famous
Variation XVIII, or some sinew, as in the ending movement
of the Fourth Concerto, pianist, conductor and orchestra were
channeling Rachmaninov.
After two and a half hours of listening, I
started pulling out old recordings for comparison's sake:
Rubenstein and Reiner, Rachmaninov and Stowkowski, Janis and
Dorati, Wild and Horenstein. I am now of the firm belief that
Hough and Litton have recorded the definitive set of the Rachmaninov
Concertos.
Hyperion's engineering is demonstration quality
and the discs sound superb as CDs or multichannel SACDs. The
differences arise where you would expect, the SACD layer being
more delicately etched and throwing a wider and deeper soundstage.
The CD layer is stunning in its own right. My only complaint,
and it is insignificant, is that the concertos are live recordings
with outbursts of applause at the end that I wish that could
have been edited out. Honestly, if I had been in the audience,
I would have applauded, too.
This is the 2004 classical recording of the
year'
The New Jersey Star-Ledger, Bradley
Bambarger, December 2004
'Some of the most popular works ever written, Rachmaninoff's
four grand piano concertos have been recorded by great pianists
from the composer himself on down. This double-disc set, though,
ranks with the very best ever made. Deep-thinking pianist
Stephen Hough displays not only amazing digital address, but
idiomatic rhythmic fluency. An ideal partner, conductor Andrew
Litton garners a world-class performance from his Texas players.
No heart-on-sleeve romantics will be disappointed, but this
pairing yields a detailed, dry-eyed lyricism that minimizes
any potential for these warhorses to cloy.
It's wonderful, too, to have a deluxe recording
produced with an American orchestra. And no recordings of
the concertos have the sonic allure of these, recorded live
in concert at Dallas' Meyerson Center by top producer Andrew
Keener in surround sound (available on the SACD version of
the release). Even better, this set comes with excellent,
copious annotation, including notes on the missing wind parts
meticulously added back to the Fourth Piano Concerto (for
the first time since the composer's 1941 recording).'
John Von Rhein,
Chicago Tribune, December 2004
'Here at last we have a major pianist using the brilliance
at his disposal to illuminate what the composer wrote, rather
than himself. Drawn mostly from live performances (the Paganini
Rhapsody was taped in studio sessions), these recordings are
true to the romantic performance practice of the composer's
time, with its emphasis on subtly expressive rubato and improvisatory
freedom.'
CD of the Month, Artistic Quality 10/10
Sound Quality,
Classicstoday.com, October 2004
'This is the best set of Rachmaninov Piano Concertos ever
recorded. You have no idea how hard I worked not to come to
this conclusion, knowing full well just how skeptically such
a claim is likely to be received. I compared Stephen Hough
to multiple Ashkenazy renditions, to Earl Wild, to Zoltan
Kocsis, to Argerich, Rubinstein, Richter, Rodriguez, and Horowitz.
I ploughed through several obscure Russian recordings, two
cycles on Naxos, and a slew of EMIs. I re-auditioned Pletnev
and sampled two separate re-masterings of Rachmaninov's own
performances. I listened with scores, then waited a few days,
and then tried again without them. I played these discs to
colleagues, to friends, and to people whose musical judgment
I trust as much if not more than my own. But the conclusion
was inescapable: there never has been a complete cycle at
this level of consistent excellence. There's no doubt about
it.
Certainly Hough has made many fine recordings
in the course of a distinguished career, but even if this
were the only sample of his work to survive we would feel
compelled to rank him among the very finest keyboard artists
before the public today. He brings virtuosity, sensitivity,
thoughtfulness, and expressive intensity to this music in
equal measure, and you will come away not just dazzled by
his pianistic prowess, but with a renewed understanding of
just how great these works truly are. I can think of no higher
praise than that.'
Fanfare Magazine, September/October
2004
'…these were revelatory discs that magnificently catch
that elusive balance—or, better yet, that dart dexterously
and sometimes disturbingly back and forth over the border—between
bracing clarity and all-engulfing lushness.
No one looking for a cutting edge will be let
down. There’s a nearly zany sparkle to the more manic
passages in the last movement of the First…the Scarlatti-esque
frenzy of the first movement of Fourth emerges with stunning
precision. There’s swing as well as sting, velvet as
well as vinegar; and harmonic nuance gets just as much attention
as textural transparency, as Hough coaxes out the music’s
characteristic warmth. Try the confessional intimacy of the
middle movement of the First, the oasis of suspended calm…
The playing is often light-fingered and never heavy…Rachmaninov’s
romanticism is never short-changed… Nor, for that matter,
will these performances disappoint anyone seeking sheer roller-coaster
thrill: you’ll want to be holding on to something stable
during the closing pages of the Third.
…these rank among the most illuminating—and
most compelling—performances in the catalogue. Whether
you’re a Rachmaninov addict looking for fresh perspectives
on the music or a neophyte looking for the cycle in up-to-date
sound, Hough and Litton can be recommended without hesitation.'
|